by Abdullah Bozkurt
A damning report by the United Nations on allegations of torture and ill treatment in Turkey’s prisons and detention centers under an extended state of emergency exposes attempts by the autocratic regime of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan to cover up the evidence.
The report by Nils Melzer, the UN special rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, on his mission to Turkey that was published by the UN Human Rights Council on Dec. 18, 2017 reveals interesting facts on large-scale rights violations. To begin with, Melzer’s visit, which took place between Nov. 27 and Dec. 2, 2016, came after the Turkish government abruptly cancelled the visit of his predecessor, Juan E. Méndez, who was scheduled to visit Turkey from Oct. 10-14, 2016. Méndez lambasted the government for the last-minute cancellation and made clear that even in a state of emergency, safeguards against torture and ill treatment and other fundamental human rights must remain in place.
On July 19, 2016, four days after a failed coup bid in Turkey, Méndez was among 10 top UN experts who set off alarm bells over the Erdoğan government’s mass arrests of thousands of judges and prosecutors including two members of the Constitutional Court with no evidence of any involvement in the attempt. “We are particularly alarmed at the sheer number of judges and prosecutors who have reportedly been suspended and arrested” the experts warned, stressing that “according to international law, judges can be suspended or removed only on serious grounds of misconduct or incompetence after fair proceedings,” they said, adding: “We call on the authorities to release and reinstate these judges and prosecutors until credible allegations of wrong doing are properly investigated and evidenced. Any sanctions taken must be in line with international standards on judicial independence.”
Following the cancellation of Méndez’s visit to Turkey, Melzer managed to complete the fact-finding trip a month later but under heavy limitations. The Erdoğan government restricted his visit to only five working days as opposed to 10 to 14 on average by most UN member-states, preventing him from doing a comprehensive analysis of the situation on the ground. The UN envoy was not able to thoroughly examine many issues that fall under his mandate because of the time restriction.
Moreover, the UN special rapporteur highlighted the apparent disconnect between the declared government policy of zero tolerance for torture and its implementation in practice. He said formal investigations and prosecutions of torture and ill-treatment allegations were extremely rare despite widespread and persistent allegations in the aftermath of the coup attempt. As a result, he concluded that a strong perception of de facto impunity for acts of torture and other forms of ill treatment had been created.
The UN envoy lays bare the terrible conditions in the aftermath of the failed coup and cites reports of “severe beatings, punches and kicking, blows with objects, falaqa, threats and verbal abuse, being forced to strip naked, rape with objects and other sexual violence or threats thereof, sleep deprivation, stress positions, and extended blindfolding and/or handcuffing for several days.” He made note of allegations of extremely overcrowded detention centers where suspects did not have adequate access to food, water or medical treatment and were kept incommunicado, without access to lawyers or relatives and without being formally charged for extended periods of time lasting up to 30 days.
Melzer’s report also gives us clues on why the Erdoğan government cancelled his predecessor’s visit. When the forensic expert in his delegation examined victims of torture, signs of ill treatment were visible only in a limited number of cases, which led the UN special rapporteur to conclude that this was because of the time that had elapsed between the alleged abuse and the visit of the UN team. They were unequivocally clear that “many detainees showed signs of anguish, distress and psychological trauma consistent with their allegations, and, in some cases, mental disturbances, such as depression and post-traumatic stress disorder requiring psychological or psychiatric support.”
The time constraint also prevented the UN team from investigating prolonged solitary confinement, which has been a deliberate and systematic part of the government persecution of critics and opponents in Turkey’s prisons. Leading critical journalists, judges and prosecutors who had investigated major corruption schemes involving Erdoğan’s family or exposed the Turkish government’s links to armed jihadist groups in Syria have been particularly singled out for such inhumane treatment, causing irreparable damage to the physical and psychological well-being of the detainees. UN Special Rapporteur Melzer said he was aware of allegations that a large number of high-ranking military officers, Supreme Court of Appeals judges, prosecutors and others had been subjected to such punishment but was unable to confirm due to the time constraints imposed on his visit. But he made a point that “prolonged (of more than 15 days) or indefinite solitary confinement contravenes the absolute prohibition of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.” He also added that because of the prisoners’ inability to communicate with the outside world, solitary confinement also gives rise to situations conducive to other acts of torture or ill treatment.








